Energy: It’s Personal

Is individual control the only way to tackle visual discomfort?

By Willard Warren

With all the bare lamp lighting in vogue today, we need a glare metric to reduce visual discomfort. We’ve adopted, and discarded, glare predictive systems including the Scissor Curve, Glare Factor, ESI (equivalent sphere illuminance), VCF (visual comfort factor) and VCP (visual comfort probability), and are now considering the CIE’s UGR system.

For reference, here’s the 10th Edition of the IES Handbook’s take on glare: “Discomfort Glare Predictive Systems give reasonable predictions of the discomfort of a group of people, but give only poor predictions of an individual’s response.” That’s like having one hand in ice water and the other in hot water—the average temperature might be acceptable, but the person would still be in pain.

We can obtain a luminaire’s luminance at any angle from the manufacturer’s photometric data—and calculate a source’s projected area and its position index—yet know nothing about the visual comfort of any occupant, who is free to move their head and shift their gaze to avoid a glare source. Maybe the only glare metric is one that mandates a maximum source brightness for luminaires and requires a minimum ambient light level in the space to mitigate the glare’s effect—plus no more dark walls and ceilings.

When the source is daylight, we could look to the example of one Zero Net Energy school in New York City that reduces daylight glare by using a window with three different horizontal window panels. The top panel is clear glass with a short reflecting shelf projecting into the room to reflect daylight deeper into the room. The middle section is an opaque solar panel that generates the building’s electricity, while the bottom panel is clear glass positioned just above the window shelf to provide a view of the weather outside.

AS OPPOSED TO AN INDIVIDUAL’S response—and when dealing with our senses, in particular we’re stuck with “consensus mandates.” To make matters worse, the biggest unknown is the tolerance in our lighting calculation. For example, the equation for calculating a room’s average illumination has the initial lamp lumens in the numerator. However, labs have reported that some companies ship lamps with up to 20% less lumens than claimed. That’s multiplied by the luminaire’s coefficient of utilization (CU), which is based upon assumed room finish reflectances, and also multiplied by an assumed maintenance factor (MF) of 0.75 or 0.80 for LEDs, by custom. The equation’s denominator has the room’s floor area, which ignores the width of the HVAC units under the windows and other built-ins.

What’s worse is the tolerance of 7-8%, plus or minus, allowed in a 120/208-V electrical system. You can get 128 volts early in the day, which can drop to 110 volts in the afternoon after heavy electric loads have been added. That alone severely reduces lamp lumen output, easily resulting in a 25% lower light level than expected.

It would be more practical to provide a dimmable task/ambient lighting system that’s controlled by the room’s occupants. At the least, that’s better than following the Lighting Library’s latest criteria of having different light levels depending on age, specifically for those over the age of 65. How do you implement that criteria—by segregating a room’s occupants by age?

The European solution is to have a low adjustable general light level for safety and to provide occupants with adjustable task lighting. In the U.S., we’ve now gone from open-plan office systems to virtual and remote communication during the pandemic—maybe the next step is to give everybody a private office so we can spend all day adjusting the lighting level.

Contributor(s)

Willard Warren

Willard Warren

Willard L. Warren, PE, LC, Fellow IES, DSA, is principal of Willard L. Warren... More info »

EP Zoom Platinum Sponsor - $20,000

What’s in it for you?

  •    Sponsor 5 Students/Emerging Professionals and the EP Day presentation platform
  •    Visibility and awareness before breakout rooms and throughout the event
  •    Opportunity to present a live or prerecorded personal closing message (15 seconds-1 minute duration)
  •    Shout-outs throughout the event
  •    Recognition as an EP Program Sponsor on all event communication
  •    Recognition on the IES Annual Conference homepage
  •    Recognition on the IES Annual Conference Emerging Professional homepage

EP Sponsorship Opportunities

Sponsor students and emerging professionals to attend the virtual Annual Conference event or the in-person Street & Area Lighting Conference. Student and EP recipients selected by Emerging Professional Committee.

EP Breakout Room Sponsor - $8,000

What do you get?

  •    Sponsor breakout room for live engagement and networking during EP Day
  •    Opportunity to present a live or prerecorded personal welcome message (15 seconds-1 minute duration)
  •    Visibility and awareness at the start of the schedule
  •    Personalized zoom backgrounds for moderators
  •    Recognition as an EP Program Sponsor on all event communication
  •    Recognition on the IES Annual Conference homepage
  •    Recognition on the IES Annual Conference Emerging Professional homepage
  •    Opportunity to provide personalized swag to attendees and moderators

EP Game Sponsor - $5,000

What are the benefits?

  •    Sponsor live interactive game session(s) during EP Day
  •    Ability to use your personal game hosting platform for the game session (IES can provide platform if needed)
  •    Be a Game Co-Host
  •    Opportunity to provide personalized swag or selection of IES publications as prize options

1 X Event Sponsor - $5,000

What’s in it for you?

  •    Visibility and awareness before breakout rooms and throughout the event – graphic image of logo
  •    Opportunity to submit a prerecorded personal opening/closing message (15 seconds-1 minute duration)
  •    Shout-outs throughout the event
  •    Recognition as a Leadership Forum Sponsor on all event communication
  •    Recognition on the Leadership Forum homepage

6 X Breakout Room Sponsor - $1,000 – (1 for each of 6 Breakout Rooms)

What do you get?

  •    Visibility and awareness at the start of the schedule – [verbal announcement/thank you]
  •    Personalized Zoom background for moderators – [moderators must use if provided by sponsor]
  •    Recognition as a Leadership Forum Sponsor on all event communication
  •    Recognition on the Leadership Forum homepage

3 X Leadership Forum Kahoot Game Sponsor - $500

What are the benefits?

  •    Sponsor live interactive Kahoot game session(s) during LF Day
  •    Be a Game Co-Host (optional)
  •    Recognition as a Leadership Forum Sponsor on all event communication
  •    Recognition on the Leadership Forum homepage

1x Gold Sponsor- $25,000

  •    Recognition as a Gold Sponsor in a fourth (1/4) page placement for 2 months in LD+A magazine
  •    Recognition as Gold sponsor on event app and all event communication, excluding Registration and Daily Digest communications
  •    Full registration for two (2) to the Annual Conference
  •    Company logo and hyperlink placed on exhibitor page within event app

2x Keynote Sponsor- $10,000

  •    2-3 minute Opening
  •    Introduce keynote speaker
  •    Company logo and hyperlink placed on exhibitor page within event app

5x Virtual Break Sponsor - $6,000

  •    Provided graphic visible during break duration
  •    Recognition as Virtual Break sponsor on event app and all event communications, excluding Registration and Daily Digest communications
  •    Full Registration for one (1) to the Annual Conference

1x Opening Session Sponsor- $5,000

  •    90-second video prior to session start
  •    Company logo and hyperlink placed on exhibitor page within event app

1x Closing Session Sponsor- $5,000

  •    90-second video prior to session start
  •    Company logo and hyperlink placed on exhibitor page within event app

1x Society Update Sponsor - $5,000

  •    Recognition as Society Update sponsor throughout web
  •    Recognition as Society Update sponsor on event app and all event communication, excluding Registration and Daily Digest communications
  •    Full registration for one (1) to attend the 2021 Annual Conference
  •    90-second video prior to session start

1x Registration Sponsor - $5,000

  •    Visibility as sole sponsor on the registration page and in all registration focused communications
  •    Company logo and hyperlink placed on exhibitor page within event app

1x Daily Digest Sponsor - $5,000

  •    Visibility as sole sponsor in all Daily Digest focused communications
  •    Recognition on event webpage and communications as Daily Digest Sponsor

10x Event App Exhibitor Page Sponsor - $1,000

  •    Company logo and hyperlink placed on exhibitor page within event app